[Potential spoiler warning--I'm doing my best to keep this spoiler-free, but discussion of thematic elements may give away
ending; if you haven't seen the film, proceed with caution.]
As far as measuring up to the original goes,
Monsters University isn't too bad. The fan service is liberally applied, the team of John Goodman and Billy Crystal
is hilarious as ever, the ending is happy, the jokes are plentiful, and the Disney element outweighs the Pixar. It's generally likeable. I wouldn't put it on my top ten worst list. On the other hand, I sure as hell wouldn't put it on my top ten best list. It doesn't even break my top 5 favorite Pixar films. (If you guessed the original
Monsters, Inc would be
in that list, you would be right.) That right there should tell you something.
Is Pixar losing their touch? I don't know. I loved
Brave, and
Toy Story 3 was as loveable a tearjerker as its predecessors. But
Monsters University missed the mark for me. It's probably because I'm a jaded film student, I'll admit. I have no doubt that die-hard Pixar followers and elementary schoolers, a.k.a.
the target audience for the film, will love it. But for me, it just didn't cut it...and not for the reasons you might think; like I said, the fan service was incredible. And yet...there was something that just felt off.
For me, the faults in the film come down to three major points:
1) The "you can be your own hero" message is lost in the mess of Hollywood cliches. Wreck-It Ralph had this problem too, and from what I saw of the previews, so will the next batch of tried-and-true Disney confections. In every film, there is a common thread: an underdog fights his/her way to the top and beats all the odds to become--ta-
da!--a
hero!
Monsters University is no exception. Underdog Mike Wazowski is shown as a hardworking, determined,
everyman kind of guy who just wants to do well in school; thus, naturally, he becomes a "hero" at his school (only after defeating the token evil popular guys, of course). I'm so sick of seeing this trope in movies I could puke. If it's "okay" to not be a hero, Disney and Pixar, then why is it that in every movie you release, there is always at least one hero, usually a token underdog like Mike? If it's okay to just be normal, then why does the good guy
always win in your films, and why
does the bad guy always lose? Why are there no
grey areas between winning and losing, heroes and villains? Which brings me to...
2) The characters are so one-dimensional it's actually sickening. Just like in every other fucking high school/college movie
ever made in the history of cinema, the popular guys are terrible
douchebags who have status but no tact, and the nerds/underdogs are lovable, compassionate, gentle, and of course brilliantly smart. There's no middle ground. The message is clear: if you're popular, you are a jerk and your appeal is fleeting; if you are not popular, you're wonderful and it's just that no one else has seen it, but don't worry, they will eventually. And of course Randall, Mike's roommate, starts off his uncool best friend, but as soon as he gets a taste of popularity, what does he do? Of
course he denounces Mike and runs off to join the ranks of the
populars--why wouldn't he? How dare you even suggest he could have stayed friends with Mike and joined the fraternity on the side? Oh no, he's
popular now, therefore he
must turn into an insufferable jerk! And of course Mike's new friends, the geeks, are all so pathetic and helpless they need their fearless leader to turn them into glorious champions. There's never any middle ground. According to Disney, you are either a forceful popular leader and a total asshole, or you're a doormat geek with no life who lives with their parents. Which brings me to...
3) The parent-child relationship is just plain nonexistent. Either the parents are helicopters, like Squishy's mom, or totally absent, like Mike's parents. There's no middle ground there, either. Squishy is a total joke for living with his mom, while poor Mike and Sulley get no support from their parents whatsoever. There's nothing that even remotely resembles a healthy parent-child relationship. Remember the perfect balance struck by the parents in
Easy A? Remember how Olive's parents loved her to bits, but also knew when to stay out of her business? Remember that natural, realistic,
balanced portrayal of a parent-child relationship? Well, you won't find it here. Remember, through a teenager's eyes, it's not possible for a parent to be anything other than an embarrassment or a parole officer.
You know what I'd like to see, just once? I'd like to see a movie where the lines are blurred. Where the popular kids are a mixed bag, just like any other group--where there are some
jerkwad popular rich snobs, but there are also some likable, Captain America-style popular kids who get involved in anything and everything and have tons of friends and
that's why they're popular. And the geeks aren't all nice and quirky and brilliant and naturally lovable, they're human just like the rest of the kids. I'd like to see friendship between the popular and unpopular, because believe it or not, that happens in real life just like the clique barrier.
I'd like to see a movie that, instead of endlessly extolling the merits of friendship, acknowledges that some people are better off on their own,
and that is perfectly okay. Not all
loners have that posse of lovable nerds to back them up. Some of them are just that--loners. They
prefer to be alone. They
like being alone. And that is
totally okay. You don't
have to have a circle of friends. You can just have one best friend, or hell, just be friends with your parents. That's okay too.
I'd like to see more movies like
Juno and
Easy A, where the parents are a part of the kid's life, a natural part of the kid's life, without taking it over or fading out of it completely. I'd like to see more movies where the parents are neither buffoons nor jailers, they're simply
parents, just people who want to do the best by the people they love most: their kids. I'd like to see more movies where the kids have a relationship with their parents like I have with mine.
I'd like to see a movie that acknowledges that, no, not every underdog will beat the odds, and not every misfit will end up a hero. Life doesn't always hand you that silver lining. Sometimes, it has to be enough just knowing that you did what was right by yourself. Sometimes, you have to be alone. Sometimes, you just have to face that
you aren't that good, and you have to find another way to get what you want. While
Monsters University touched on this briefly, the film would have been so much better if it actually went in-depth--meaning, yes, Mike realizes he just isn't that scary. And I love that. But instead of showing an alternate path, he just finds another way to indirectly be a
scarer. And all the geeks, all the other underdogs, what happens to them? They become
scarers too.
I want to see a movie about an ordinary person doing ordinary things and being happy with who they are even though they aren't secretly a heroic
badass who can save the day when everyone else is saying "You're not enough." I want someone who will look back at those naysayers and reply, "No, I am not enough, I will never be enough to save the day, but you know what? I'm enough by myself, and I'm proud of who I am even though I'm not 'enough' for you." I want to see a movie like that.
Hmm...I think I'll write one.