When I heard him say this, I was newly eighteen and in love with someone who I knew would never, in a million years, want me back. And as my poetry-choked journals of that year can attest, I heartily agreed with him.
But now? Now, I don't know if he was right. Well, he was right about love sucking in every possible setting. He was right on target about that. But I don't know if I have enough words, much less great words, to describe how I feel right now.
What no one tells you about breakups when you're young, when you're just starting out, is that there are three kinds. There are mutual ones, the kind where neither of you has to initiate it, it just happens. Then there's the kind where you get dumped. (Between the ages of fifteen and twenty, this happened to me twice. Neither time was particularly pleasant, but that was no surprise.) And then there's the kind where you have to break it off.
And maybe someone else will disagree. But I'd take the first two over the last one any day.
When you are dumped you may blame yourself (I know I did), but when you break up with someone, there is a certain kind of guilt that comes with it, especially when you know the other person still has feelings for you. You think, I am an awful person. I am selfish. I am breaking their heart just like [other person] did to me once. I should be ashamed of myself.
This is what I felt for days and days after my breakup. But I felt even worse when I realized, I wasn't. Ashamed of myself, I mean. I was hurt, I was vulnerable, I was scared. I was even a little bit angry. But I wasn't ashamed.
And then I realized, wait, what's that last one? That last feeling, hiding right there under all the other ones? Oh, that's anger! I'm angry, why am I angry? I broke up with her, not the other way around. If anyone has the right to be angry, it's her! And then I realized why I was angry with her, what caused me to break up with her in the first place [I won't list those reasons here - it's between me and her], and I felt better just because I understood something. It wasn't much, I still felt like the world had inverted itself, but I understood something about what had just happened.
Then I cried. A lot. Because I don't care how angry you are, when you were in love with someone, really in love with them, and you hear what was once "your song" on the radio, you are going to cry. Unless that person did something awful enough to deserve your hatred, like physically or emotionally abused you (and, for the record, she never did that, ever), you are going to feel all of that stuff well up inside you, and you won't remember broken promises or cancelled dates or all the sacrifices you made that went unnoticed. You are going to remember the time she held you when a zombie at Six Flags tried to scare you, or the way it felt the first time she kissed you, or the time she went out of her way to bring you soup when you were sick.
You will remember all of that, and you will cry. Hard.
And that is what no one tells you about the third kind of breakup: it hurts just as much to break up with someone as it does to be broken up with.
There will be people who don't understand this, as I learned the hard way. I'd go to certain friends for comfort, and hear "Well you did break up with her," as if this somehow negated my eligibility for sadness. As if the moment I said, "I don't think this is working for either of us," I gave up my right to feel the loss of the girl I thought would be my future wife.
And that's the bottom line for me, is that I did think we were going to end up married. I did think that I would never love anyone else. I was so, so, so sure, beyond sure, that we would never break up. I would never again feel lonely or unwanted. Except...wait. Weren't there times, even when I was with her, that I did feel lonely or unwanted? A missed call here, a cancelled date there, a "sorry honey, later" every now and then...okay, maybe it wasn't perfect, but for a year and a half I was a girlfriend. I was a fiancee. I wasn't "just" me, "just" Avery. I was part of something.
But, wait...
Why do I think that way? Why do I only "count" when my identity is wrapped up in someone else's? Why did I feel so happy on the good days, walking along, thinking about how cool it was to OMG HAVE A GIRLFRIEND? Even on bad days I'd think, "Well, at least you're not alone. Stop sulking, this is what you wanted. Maybe she isn't right here next to you right now. Maybe she's not perfect. But you wanted a mate and you have a mate. Stop complaining." I'd look at my Facebook relationship status - "In a relationship," "engaged" - and feel so much better about myself than I did when I was single.
I don't think that way anymore, though.
Okay, maybe I don't have people lining up at the door to "replace" the girl I just broke up with. (I won't get into rebound etiquette, but seriously, don't try to replace one person with another. People are not iPods. You cannot transfer emotional data from one to the other.) But that does not make me less of a person. You could argue, even, that I am more worthy of respect, because I recognized a situation that was unhealthy for both me and my partner and ended the bad situation before either of us got more hurt than we already were.
I still miss her. I still cry. But I don't beat myself up. I don't think "what was wrong with me that I couldn't make it work." I think about her. I think, to some extent, part of me will always love her. I'll certainly never forget her. But holding her to me when there were things I wanted that she couldn't deliver - that wasn't fair to her or to me. And I'd be a truly awful person if I'd let that continue just because I was afraid of what might happen if we ended our relationship. (I might be alone forever. She might hate me. Our friends might turn against me. Fill in the blank.)
And I don't think of myself as "just me" anymore. With or without a girlfriend, I still exist. That doesn't change because of my relationship status. I'm still a film geek, Whovian, blogger, Episcopalian, part-Irish, part-Scottish, part-Welsh (I swear I could not get whiter if I tried), ENFP, writer, pansexual, Loki fan, patriarchy-hater, awkward, weight-lifter, Just Dance enthusiast. I'm still a person. There is so much that I love about myself and so much that I want to change about myself. That does not change when I go from "in a relationship" to "single."
I am not "just a girlfriend."
I am not "just a fiancee."
I am not "just" anything.
I am me. And I will stay that way for a long time.
You will remember all of that, and you will cry. Hard.
And that is what no one tells you about the third kind of breakup: it hurts just as much to break up with someone as it does to be broken up with.
There will be people who don't understand this, as I learned the hard way. I'd go to certain friends for comfort, and hear "Well you did break up with her," as if this somehow negated my eligibility for sadness. As if the moment I said, "I don't think this is working for either of us," I gave up my right to feel the loss of the girl I thought would be my future wife.
And that's the bottom line for me, is that I did think we were going to end up married. I did think that I would never love anyone else. I was so, so, so sure, beyond sure, that we would never break up. I would never again feel lonely or unwanted. Except...wait. Weren't there times, even when I was with her, that I did feel lonely or unwanted? A missed call here, a cancelled date there, a "sorry honey, later" every now and then...okay, maybe it wasn't perfect, but for a year and a half I was a girlfriend. I was a fiancee. I wasn't "just" me, "just" Avery. I was part of something.
But, wait...
Why do I think that way? Why do I only "count" when my identity is wrapped up in someone else's? Why did I feel so happy on the good days, walking along, thinking about how cool it was to OMG HAVE A GIRLFRIEND? Even on bad days I'd think, "Well, at least you're not alone. Stop sulking, this is what you wanted. Maybe she isn't right here next to you right now. Maybe she's not perfect. But you wanted a mate and you have a mate. Stop complaining." I'd look at my Facebook relationship status - "In a relationship," "engaged" - and feel so much better about myself than I did when I was single.
I don't think that way anymore, though.
Okay, maybe I don't have people lining up at the door to "replace" the girl I just broke up with. (I won't get into rebound etiquette, but seriously, don't try to replace one person with another. People are not iPods. You cannot transfer emotional data from one to the other.) But that does not make me less of a person. You could argue, even, that I am more worthy of respect, because I recognized a situation that was unhealthy for both me and my partner and ended the bad situation before either of us got more hurt than we already were.
I still miss her. I still cry. But I don't beat myself up. I don't think "what was wrong with me that I couldn't make it work." I think about her. I think, to some extent, part of me will always love her. I'll certainly never forget her. But holding her to me when there were things I wanted that she couldn't deliver - that wasn't fair to her or to me. And I'd be a truly awful person if I'd let that continue just because I was afraid of what might happen if we ended our relationship. (I might be alone forever. She might hate me. Our friends might turn against me. Fill in the blank.)
And I don't think of myself as "just me" anymore. With or without a girlfriend, I still exist. That doesn't change because of my relationship status. I'm still a film geek, Whovian, blogger, Episcopalian, part-Irish, part-Scottish, part-Welsh (I swear I could not get whiter if I tried), ENFP, writer, pansexual, Loki fan, patriarchy-hater, awkward, weight-lifter, Just Dance enthusiast. I'm still a person. There is so much that I love about myself and so much that I want to change about myself. That does not change when I go from "in a relationship" to "single."
I am not "just a girlfriend."
I am not "just a fiancee."
I am not "just" anything.
I am me. And I will stay that way for a long time.