So I kind of just really need to get this out...
Okay, so in context, that song is actually about not being able to get over an ex-lover. Right. I get that. But I'm using it to mean something a little different in this case. I don't mean "cut" as in "wound." I mean "cut" as in "impression." As in, the first impression is the deepest. The first impression lasts the longest, and the first impression I had of the subject of this blog post was intense, to say the least.
I love movies. I love making them, and watching them, and writing them, and writing about them. I have seen way too many movies, and there were definitely a few in there that I regretted seeing (Diary of the Dead--no. Just. No), but there were so many that I loved that I always pause for a moment when someone asks, "So, what's your favorite movie?"
I have a few kinds of "favorite movies." Of course there are the ones I love because they are, cinematically speaking, phenomenal. Then there's the favorites that I know I really shouldn't love, but I do anyway--the "guilty pleasure" list, if you will. There are the ones that I love and hate at the same time, because they're beautiful but painful to watch. (Yes,
Django Unchained, I'm looking at you.)
And then there are the ones I love not because they're aesthetically pleasing or well-written or well-cast or for any other superficial reason, but just because...well...
I just love them. They make me laugh, they make me cry, they make me angry, they make me feel all warm inside. They make me
feel, period. They give me something I can't get from any other movie. Sometimes they have cinematic value or historical value; sometimes they don't. I don't care; I just love them for what they are.
The last category has a subcategory I like to call "Films that Make Me Want to Make More Films." Every time I watch one of these, I immediately go to my computer or camera as soon as the credits roll and start working on my own screenplays, treatments, or photographs. More often than not, what I write isn't based on or
derivative of whatever I've just watched--but there have been pieces I've written or photographed heavily inspired by these "Films that Make Me Want to Make More Films," henceforth known as FMMWMMF (hey, that's a palindrome!).
And if you look at these FMMWMMF, most of them are not exactly about to be nominated for an Academy Award. They are films like
Shopgirl or
Back to the Future, films that are beautifully
made but often overlooked by critics as "chick flicks" or "summer hits." Not to say I can't appreciate the classics; I can--but after watching something like
2001: A Space Odyssey or
Titanic (both films I strongly dislike, by the way), I'm too mentally exhausted to go straight into my own work. And there's a huge difference between directors I love because they're brilliant--Hitchcock, Tarantino, and Michael Moore being prime examples--and directors I love because
they fucking get it. Directors whose films make me feel welcomed, accepted; directors whose films make me feel I am not alone with my weird little brain and off-the-wall ideas.
Christopher Nolan.
Anand Tucker.
Gus Van Sant.
Jeff Malmberg.
And believe it or not...
This guy.
Oh, yes. I went there.
Go ahead, laugh at me all you like. Tell me how awful his films have been in recent years, and I'll agree with you. Yes, he needs to shape up. Yes, he needs to get some new material. Yes, he needs to fucking
stop casting Johnny Depp; for the love of God, Burton, he won't be offended if you give him some time off now and then...
But...well...
I like him.
I mean I like him a
lot.
I mean when I was fourteen I had a giant crush on him.
I mean I had pictures of him on my phone.
I mean I had posters of his films in my room.
I mean I made it my mission to watch
every single thing that he released. Including the short films. And his student films. (Still haven't succeeded in that last one, by the way. But I've not given up yet.)
I mean I practically idolized this guy. I used to imagine that he was my best friend. I'd imagine conversations with him, imagine going to high school with him so that being in an online program didn't seem quite as lonely--this was before I went to Interlochen--and when I held my imaginary proms or homecoming dances upstairs, he was always my imaginary date. Even when I actually went to a real high school, with real people and real, age-appropriate crushes, I still obsessively watched his films. I kept a journal of my reactions to and reflections on his movies, his characters, and his poetry and photography. I felt like this was someone, a grown-up, a
successful grown-up, a successful grown-up outside of my family, a successful grown-up outside my family with talents that I desperately wanted to develop, who I could understand.
Until I found Tim Burton I wanted to be an actress. I wanted to be Jodie Foster, Kathy Bates, Mary Stuart Masterson. Okay, no, that was what I wanted on an intellectual level, but what I actually fantasized about was being Hilary Duff. That was what I really wanted. I wanted recognition from an adoring crowd, millions of screaming fans, movies, pop albums, clothing lines. I wanted to be Magazine Pop Star Girl. I wanted to be rich and famous and, like so many other
tweenage girls, I wanted to be a princess.
And then I saw my first horror movie, and everything changed.
I can't accurately describe the effect that
Sleepy Hollow had on me, but I'll give it my best shot. It felt like a curtain had been lifted and I was being shown a whole new world, a whole new way of watching a film. Until that point I'd watched films for
story, purely for content. This time I was watching it for the lighting, the colors, the cinematography, the design, the sets, the sheer aesthetic pleasure of it all. I was frightened--a girl like me couldn't help but feel like that, watching a film where gory decapitation was a prominent feature of the story--but I could still get enjoyment out of the experience. And I loved it. Oh, how I loved every minute of it.
My next foray into Burtonland was
Nightmare Before Christmas...strangely enough in early spring, nowhere near Christmas or Halloween. I didn't care. I watched every second of it, feeling as though the characters in the movie had been written just for me. Unlike
Sleepy Hollow, this was a movie I could watch and admire and analyze...and still sleep at night. It was a movie where not just the aesthetic, but the
story spoke to me in ways I'd never before imagined. And I wanted more.
Still, it wasn't until I was about fourteen or so that I really hit my Burton phase. I read his biographies and autobiographies. I read as much about him as I could get my hands on. I watched his movies and analyzed them with a fervor that, to that point, I had only dedicated to Harry Potter. I watched his interviews on YouTube. I saw
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory in theaters--my first new-release Burton film--when I was twelve; asked for the DVD for my thirteenth birthday. When I got my first cell phone in eighth grade, I set his picture as my background. For my first research paper in my freshman year of high school...well, you can guess who I chose as my topic.
To this day I find it difficult to pinpoint exactly what it was that drew me to Tim Burton's work, sucked me in and held me there with an ironclad grip. I think it was mostly timing. I wasn't the typical little preteen; I noticed boys, I liked boys, but I had a hard time relating to girls my own age, because they seemed shallow to me. It was all about where your jeans came from, or which version of the iPod you had, or how many things your cell phone could do. And I tried to be part of that, but it always ended in misery for me. I can't tell you how many times I tried to be part of a "cool" group but couldn't make it work. Keep in mind, at age twelve, I was still playing with my Barbies and American Girl dolls and Playmobil, but at the same time, I was reading parenting magazines and learning how advertising works and discussing Stanley Milgram's experiments with my mother. So that was the kind of kid I was...and yet it wasn't until watching films like
Nightmare Before Christmas that I understood just who I was. I wasn't meant to be
Pop Princess; I was meant to be
me.
And on top of that, there was the feminism aspect. Look at how girls are portrayed in the media: we're supposed to care about nothing but boys and clothes and tech toys. Even the "heroines" are dressed in tight clothes; the female superheroes, like Batgirl and Supergirl, wear skirts and are counterparts to male
superheores. So watching something like
Beetle Juice, where the "weird girl" saves the day, or
Batman Returns, where Catwoman virtually sacrifices herself to kill Shreck even though she has the choice to run off with Bruce Wayne, was very appealing to me. It showed me a new kind of heroine, the kind who had to make hard choices that had nothing to do with which dress to wear to the prom. But at the same time, I always knew it was
okay to care about what you wore to the prom, but it was equally important to understand that
it's okay to care about other things too.
And then there was the filmmaking angle, and once I went to a "real" high school and started studying
moviemaking seriously, Tim Burton became even more important to me. He really drew my attention to directing, because his films aren't character-driven, they're more settings-driven. An exception to this would be something like
Edward Scissorhands, where the character is so perfect for the settings and he's a well-developed character--and I adore
Edward Scissorhands, by the way, because I spent my teen years in a housing development, so I could identify with it as well as appreciate the artistic elements of it--but watch something like
Beetle Juice. Who the hell is Betelgeuse, anyway? No one knows, no one cares. Who is Otho? Who are the Deetzes? No one cares, because they're in this rich environment and they're so wild, they're all absolutely crazy and their environment is so perfectly created that you love them anyway. Until I started watching Burton's films, I never understood that you didn't
have to follow the structure--Underdog Becomes Hero And Slowly Wins Over The Girl, or Misunderstood Girl Becomes Popular And Gets The Guy. You could write other things. You could do things like
Beetle Juice, parodies and comedies and mysteries and a little bit of horror, all wrapped into one.
I wouldn't say my films are just like that--on occasion, some element of a Burton film might inspire me, but I never try to re-create what he's done. I'm more on the side of realism--think Anand Tucker or Diablo Cody--but he's still important to me, because he first drew my attention to the concept of filmmaking as an art. And that right there is the bottom line. If I'd never seen
Sleepy Hollow, I would not have wanted to become a director, or a screenwriter. It's that simple. I never would have gone to Interlochen, read
Girl Director and
Make Your Own Damn Movie, studied the work of Hitchcock and Kubrick, or taken a college class that required me to write a full feature-length screenplay in less than four months.
Imagine my distress, then, when the reaction to my love for Tim Burton, nine times out of ten, consists of "Oh...you like
that guy."
Yes. Yes, I do. And no, you do not get to judge me for it. And if you do, I will judge you for liking James Cameron (who, in addition to directing some damn terrible movies--watch
Avatar and seriously tell me he's got any shred of creativity--is a flaming a-hole) and Francis Ford Coppola (I don't care what anyone says,
The Godfather is a
trainwreck in terms of script. Period.).
Watching Tim Burton films gives me hope. His work tells me, with every flaw, every bad casting choice, every repeated storyline and every awkward line of dialogue, that I have hope of becoming a filmmaker. His work tells me that the awkwardly extroverted young girl who made Playmobil shorts with her father, who wrote stories in which her pet rabbit could talk, who once filmed her every move and called it "the Avery Udell TV Show," can someday turn into a legitimate filmmaker whose work speaks to other awkward young girls much like herself. I still tear up at
Ed Wood--because I fucking
am Ed Wood. You really think that I'm delusional enough to think that I will ever win an Oscar? I'm not--I will not be a Hollywood darling. I know this. But I still
try. I wrote a feature script in four months. I sent my films into festivals. When they weren't accepted, I found a best friend and started making shorts--and the president of my college noticed. Did I care that he wasn't the president of the Academy? No--because he noticed, and he cared, and that was enough. I don't care, I truly don't, that I am destined to be a writer--and be virtually anonymous. If I touch one person the way Tim Burton has touched me, then I will be happy.
So yes, I still believe in Tim Burton. And when
Big Eyes hits theaters next summer, I will be first in line to buy a ticket. (Christoph Waltz and Amy Adams starring in a Tim Burton film? Yes, please.) And yes, I still credit him for introducing me to the world of filmmaking as an art. Is this
unfeminist of me? Should I perhaps be gushing over Kathryn Bigelow, Jamie Babbit, Kimberly Peirce, Catherine Hardwicke, Julie Davis--the women who made the independent films that I so love, whose style of filmmaking is so much closer to mine than that of the wild, surrealist Tim Burton? Maybe. But the fact remains that it wasn't
Boys Don't Cry or
Thirteen that sucked me into the artistic world of filmmaking and held me there while I found my niche--it was
Sleepy Hollow and
The Nightmare Before Christmas and
Edward Scissorhands.
I still believe in you, Mr. Burton. And I won't give up on you...no matter how many more like
Dark Shadows you make. Keep doing what you're doing. When you make another film that I fall in love with, I'll be the first to reaffirm your brilliance.
Just...
please promise you'll keep exploring new actors, won't you? I love Johnny Depp as much as the next person, but there are others who would be so very well suited to your style, you know.